A Question Without a Clear Answer
Book a week at a thermal spa and you might leave feeling refreshed. Add blood tests, a physician consultation and a tailored nutrition plan, and something shifts. But into what category?
That question divided a panel at the Health Tourism Conference in Baku, where industry figures tried to pin down where wellness holidays end and medical tourism begins. The discussion, led by László Puczkó of HTWWLife, showed just how contested the boundary remains.
Lutz Lungwitz of the German Medical Wellness Association proposed splitting the field into three camps: medical tourism for people seeking procedures, medical wellness for supervised health improvement, and wellness tourism for relaxation and lifestyle. Puczkó pushed back immediately, asking whether prevention could really be separated from daily habits.
Emil Hidayatli, chief physician at TABIA Group, argued that the two overlap. He works in lifestyle medicine, where diet, movement and natural therapies are prescribed to prevent illness. What marks it as medical, he said, is the presence of trained professionals who assess each guest and design individual programmes. The goal extends past the visit itself: guests should be supported to maintain changes once they go home.
That ambition sounds sensible. But if both a standard spa and a medically supervised retreat encourage healthier living, how is a traveller supposed to tell them apart?
Destinations Under Pressure to Adapt
For some places, the debate is not abstract. Kateřina Adámková runs Císařské lázně, a spa in Karlovy Vary. Czech spa towns were built around multi-week treatment courses, but those long stays no longer fit most people's schedules. The loss of Russian visitors has added urgency to the search for new markets, including guests interested in shorter, medically oriented programmes.
Thomas Bömkes, a health tourism adviser to ITB Berlin, suggested that attracting younger visitors requires expanding what is on offer. Cooking classes, sleep coaching and mental health support might help guests see the trip as the start of something, not just an escape. If people leave with tools they can use at home, he said, they are more likely to come back.
The Promise Problem
Puczkó pressed the panel on what guests should actually expect to gain. Medical procedures deliver concrete results: a filled tooth, a repaired joint. What is the equivalent in wellness?
Hidayatli warned against overpromising. Some metrics can be checked during a stay, but real change takes time and depends on what guests do afterwards. Puczkó questioned whether that message would resonate with younger consumers who want visible proof.
Hidayatli pointed to wearable trackers and apps as one way to help guests monitor themselves after leaving. But the tension remained: if benefits are long-term and self-directed, what exactly is being sold?
Bömkes offered his own experience as an answer. He spent two weeks at an Ayurveda centre in India, where daily treatments, dietary changes and proper rest left him feeling noticeably better. He said he did not need data to validate the experience; the improvement was enough to make him want to return each year. Friends he told about the trip have since gone themselves.
That personal endorsement has marketing power. But it also sidesteps the question of what makes the benefit medical rather than simply restorative.
Who Decides What Counts as Medical?
The conversation sharpened when regulation came up. If a service calls itself medical, what standards should apply?
Hidayatli favoured certification that involves relevant government bodies. Bömkes said health-related claims should be regulated by authorities, while other aspects could be managed by industry groups. Lungwitz described his association's work on a certification scheme that combines medical oversight with hospitality quality measures. He also questioned whether the word "tourism" fits when someone travels specifically for treatment.
Underneath the different proposals was a shared concern: trust. Travellers need to know what they are buying, who is responsible for their care, and what a provider can legitimately claim.
Three Audiences, Three Offers
The line between wellness and medical care depends partly on who the service is designed for. A tourist wants relaxation and perhaps some healthier habits. A patient needs diagnosis, treatment and clinical oversight. A client investing in a personalised health programme sits somewhere in between, expecting professional guidance but not necessarily treatment for illness.
Each group has different expectations and requires different safeguards. For destinations trying to position themselves, clarity about the target audience is the foundation. Without it, marketing becomes muddled and travellers are left guessing what they are actually signing up for.
The Baku panel did not resolve the question. But it made clear that the industry has not yet settled on an answer, and that ambiguity has consequences for everyone involved.








